Gusto vs ADP RUN: Payroll for Small US Businesses in 2026
As of 17 November 2026, Gusto is the clearest buy in a Gusto vs ADP RUN comparison for most small US businesses, because its prices are published: Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person. ADP RUN publishes no price at all, and QuickBooks Payroll is cheaper on paper at $50 plus $7 per employee but ties you to Intuit.
TL;DR:
- Gusto Simple costs $49 a month plus $6 per person, so a 10-person business pays $109 a month; Gusto Plus costs $80 plus $12, or $200 for 10 people.
- QuickBooks Workforce Payroll lists $50 a month plus $7 per employee ($120 for 10), with 70% off the base fee for three months in its sale ending 29 November 2026.
- ADP RUN publishes no price, targets businesses with 1 to 49 employees, and offers up to six months of free payroll under terms ADP links from its page.
- The IRS requires e-filing once you file 10 or more information returns in total, so any tool you pick must e-file both W-2 and 1099 forms.
- Accountants get a free Gusto Pro dashboard; the other two are quote or client-by-client decisions, so test with one real client first.
Table of Contents
- Which is better for a small business: Gusto, ADP RUN or QuickBooks Payroll?
- How much does each payroll tool cost at 5, 10 and 25 employees?
- What does each one include, and where does each fall short?
- What do US payroll rules mean for the choice?
- Which one should an accounting firm recommend to clients?
- How do you test the choice before moving a client?
- Copy this: payroll provider shortlist sheet
- Why does independent evidence matter when choosing payroll software?
- Realistic expectations: a payroll switch is a quarter-end project
- Find your next payroll tool through The AI Ledger
- Frequently asked questions
Which is better for a small business: Gusto, ADP RUN or QuickBooks Payroll?
Gusto is the better default for most businesses with 1 to 50 staff, because you can see the price, the plan limits and the accountant tools before you talk to anyone. In The AI Ledger directory, Gusto ↗ holds an editor score of 4.6 out of 5, the highest of the payroll tools in our directory. Our verdict calls it reliable, clearly priced US payroll with a free dashboard for firms. The listing was verified against the vendor's site on 13 November 2026.
ADP RUN wins in a different case. It is built for businesses with 1 to 49 employees, ADP lists 24/7 real-person payroll support across its packages, and it offers four tiers that stretch from core payroll up to HR with legal assistance through a third party. If the client already uses ADP for benefits or wants a large provider's HR help desk, that matters more than a published price.
QuickBooks Payroll wins where the books already live in QuickBooks Online. Intuit sells it as QuickBooks Workforce Payroll in three tiers, and the Elite tier adds tax penalty protection covering IRS penalties and interest up to $25,000 a year, subject to Intuit's terms.
The table compares the three on the points a buyer actually needs. We could not confirm hosting location or whether any of the three trains models on client data from the pages we read, so those cells say "not stated". Check each vendor's trust page before you move a client.
| Tool | Editor score | Price at 10 employees | Data hosting | Trains on client data? | Ledger link |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto Simple | 4.6 out of 5 | $109 a month ($49 + 10 x $6) | Not stated on pages read | Not stated | Not stated on pages read |
| ADP RUN | Not scored (ADP Assist scores 4.0) | Quote only | Not stated on pages read | Not stated | Not stated on pages read |
| QuickBooks Workforce Payroll | Not scored as US payroll | $120 a month ($50 + 10 x $7) | Not stated on pages read | Not stated | Native to QuickBooks Online |
For ADP, see our listing for ADP Assist, the agent layer that works best where clients already run ADP. It is a separate product from RUN, so its score is not a score for RUN.
How much does each payroll tool cost at 5, 10 and 25 employees?
At 10 employees, Gusto Simple costs $109 a month, QuickBooks Workforce Payroll costs $120 and ADP RUN cannot be priced without a quote. Sources: Gusto's prices come from our directory record verified on 13 November 2026; Intuit's come from its payroll pricing page read on 17 November 2026; ADP's page says to request pricing.
The arithmetic is base fee plus the per-person fee times headcount. Gusto Simple is $49 + $6n, Plus is $80 + $12n and Premium is $180 + $22n. QuickBooks lists Workforce Payroll at $50 + $7n, Premium at $88 + $13n and Elite at $134 + $17n.
| Employees | Gusto Simple | Gusto Plus | QuickBooks Payroll | QuickBooks Premium | ADP RUN |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | $79 | $140 | $85 | $153 | Quote |
| 10 | $109 | $200 | $120 | $218 | Quote |
| 25 | $199 | $380 | $225 | $413 | Quote |
Annualised for 10 people, Gusto Simple is $1,308 and QuickBooks Workforce Payroll is $1,440, a gap of $132 a year in Gusto's favour at list price. The gap is small enough that features, not price, should decide it.
The QuickBooks promotion changes the first quarter only. Intuit's page shows 70% off the base fee for three months in a sale it marks as ending 29 November 2026. On Workforce Payroll that turns $50 into $15, so a 10-person business pays $85 a month for three months, then $120. The page shows the same per-employee rate in the sale, so the discount appears to apply to the base fee only.
ADP advertises up to six months of free payroll, subject to terms on a linked page that we did not read in full. Treat that as a negotiation opening and ask for the post-promotion price in writing, because the quote is where ADP's real cost appears.
Pro Tip: Compare the month-seven price, not the month-one price. Sales on both QuickBooks and ADP end, and the list price afterwards is the number your client lives with.
What does each one include, and where does each fall short?
ADP and QuickBooks both say they file payroll taxes; the differences sit in time tracking, HR depth, support and what the client must buy on top. Here is what the vendors say on their own pages, and where each has a weak spot.
Gusto. Our directory records three plans (Simple, Plus and Premium) and a free Gusto Pro account for accountants. Where it falls short: the bundled features by plan were not readable on Gusto's own pricing page when we checked, because the page blocked automated access, so confirm plan contents on the day before you quote a client. The quoted price also climbs steeply from Simple to Plus, $109 to $200 for 10 people.
ADP RUN. Intuit and Gusto publish prices; ADP does not. ADP says RUN calculates payroll taxes and can file federal, state and local payroll taxes with authorisation, generates and e-files W-2 and 1099 forms, and uses AI to flag likely payroll errors. Where it falls short: no public price means no way to compare before a sales call, and the survey ADP cites on its page (1,281 customers) is its own, not independent.
QuickBooks Workforce Payroll. The base tier includes full-service payroll with tax filing and payment, unlimited 1099 e-filing, next-day direct deposit and background checks. Premium adds same-day direct deposit when payroll is run by 7:00 AM, plus HR tools. Where it falls short: the page did not list contractor payment pricing, and the real value is highest only for clients already on QuickBooks Online. For UK readers, our QuickBooks listing covers the UK ledger, not US payroll.
If you are weighing broader platforms, Rippling ↗ suits clients who want payroll, HR and IT in one system, and our Deel vs Rippling comparison covers that decision. For multi-state clients, see Warp, and for startups that want a bundled back office, Every. Established mid-market buyers may prefer Paylocity.
What do US payroll rules mean for the choice?
The IRS rules do not favour any one of the three, but they set what each must do for you: deposit taxes on the right schedule and file the right forms on time. The IRS says employers deposit federal income tax withheld plus both halves of Social Security and Medicare tax, on either a monthly or a semi-weekly deposit schedule, chosen before the start of each calendar year using Publication 15.
Form 941 is the quarterly return and Form 940 is the annual federal unemployment return, according to the IRS employment tax due dates page. Recipient statements for information returns such as W-2 and 1099 are generally due by 31 January.
Two 1099 facts matter for contractor-heavy clients. The IRS 1099-NEC instructions say the reporting threshold for certain payments rose to $2,000 for payments in years beginning after 2025, with inflation adjustment possible from 2027. They also say the e-file threshold is 10 returns, counted across all information return types together, following T.D. 9972.
In practice, a client with four W-2s and six 1099-NECs must e-file, so any of the three tools needs to e-file both form types. ADP says RUN e-files W-2 and 1099 forms, and QuickBooks lists unlimited 1099 e-filing in its base tier. Confirm Gusto's coverage when you test.
Which one should an accounting firm recommend to clients?
Recommend Gusto when the client wants the lowest published price and your firm wants a free dashboard, ADP RUN when HR support and a large provider matter, and QuickBooks Payroll when the client is already in QuickBooks Online. The decision rule is simple, and it also protects you if the client asks why you chose one.
Choose Gusto if the client has 1 to 25 staff, runs on a cloud ledger and wants a quoted price today. Gusto Pro is free for accountants in our directory data, which lets a firm see several clients in one place.
Choose ADP RUN if the client wants phone-first support, expects to grow into HR help, or already uses ADP elsewhere. Accept that you will negotiate the price.
Choose QuickBooks Payroll if the books are in QuickBooks Online and the client values same-day deposit on Premium or the Elite penalty protection. Check the per-employee fee as the team grows: at 25 employees Premium costs $413 a month.
Do not choose on price alone: the $132 annual difference at 10 employees is small next to the cost of a mis-filed quarter. If you want a wider shortlist, use the payroll and HR category and the finder, and read our payroll automation guide.
| Situation | Best fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 to 25 staff, wants published pricing | Gusto Simple | $49 + $6 per person, visible before any sales call |
| Client already in QuickBooks Online | QuickBooks Payroll | Same vendor as the ledger, 70% off base fee in the current sale |
| Wants HR support and a large provider | ADP RUN | Four tiers up to HR with legal assistance via a third party |
| Needs tax penalty protection | QuickBooks Elite | Up to $25,000 a year, subject to terms |
| Needs an accountant dashboard | Gusto | Gusto Pro is free for accountants |
How do you test the choice before moving a client?
Run a parallel test on one real pay run before committing. It takes one pay period and exposes the problems a demo hides. Follow these steps:
- Ask each vendor for the written price for your exact headcount, including month seven onwards, and note the date.
- Request a sandbox or trial account and enter three representative employees: one salaried, one hourly, one with a garnishment or benefit deduction.
- Compare gross to net pay against the client's last real payroll, line by line.
- Check the tax deposit schedule the tool uses against the one the IRS assigned to the client.
- Export the payroll journal and test the posting into the client's ledger. Note whether it posts back automatically.
- Ask the vendor in writing where client data is hosted and whether it is used to train models.
- Keep the current provider running until one full quarter has filed on the new one.
Pro Tip: Mid-quarter switches create two sets of Form 941 figures. Starting on 1 January or the first day of a quarter keeps filings clean.
Copy this: payroll provider shortlist sheet
Paste this into a spreadsheet and fill one row per vendor, one sheet per client. Fields marked "ask" should be answered in writing.
| Field | Gusto | ADP RUN | QuickBooks Payroll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headcount quoted for | |||
| Base fee per month | |||
| Per-person fee | |||
| Month 1 to 3 total (promo) | |||
| Month 7 total (list) | |||
| Contractor payment fee (ask) | |||
| State and local tax filing included (ask) | |||
| Same-day or next-day deposit | |||
| W-2 and 1099 e-file included | |||
| Penalty protection or guarantee | |||
| Data hosting location (ask) | |||
| Trains on client data (ask) | |||
| Ledger posting: read only or write back | |||
| Accountant access and fee | |||
| Contract length and exit terms | |||
| Decision and date |
Total cost over 12 months = (base fee + per-person fee x headcount) x 12, adjusted for any promotional months.
Why does independent evidence matter when choosing payroll software?
Vendors write their own pricing pages and customer surveys, so a figure such as ADP's 1,281-customer survey tells you what ADP wants you to believe, not what an unrelated reviewer would find. Independent editor scores, written verdicts and last-verified dates give you a second view that a sales page cannot.
The AI Ledger scores tools against published evidence, dates each verification and says plainly when a vendor does not state something. You can browse every listing and its last-verified date in the directory, and compare shortlisted tools side by side in compare. Where a deal is live, we list it on deals and keep it separate from the verdict.
Realistic expectations: a payroll switch is a quarter-end project
Plan a payroll migration as a one-quarter project, not a weekend task. Expect to run old and new systems in parallel, expect at least one tax-setup question the vendor must resolve, and expect the saving at list price to be smaller than the sales page suggests.
Prices change. The QuickBooks sale ends 29 November 2026, and per-person fees rise with headcount, so a business that adds 10 staff pays $70 more a month on QuickBooks Workforce Payroll and $60 more on Gusto Simple.
Find your next payroll tool through The AI Ledger
Start with the payroll and HR category, which lists payroll tools with an editor score, a pricing summary and a last-verified date. Then use the finder to narrow the list to the tools that fit your clients' size and ledger. If a tool is not listed, tell us and we will check it against the vendor's own pages.
Frequently asked questions
Is Gusto cheaper than ADP RUN?
Gusto publishes its price, so you can calculate it: Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person, which is $109 a month for 10 employees. ADP RUN publishes no price and quotes by request, so a true comparison needs a written ADP quote for your headcount, including the price after any free-payroll promotion ends.
How much does QuickBooks Payroll cost per month?
As of 17 November 2026, Intuit lists QuickBooks Workforce Payroll at $50 a month plus $7 per employee, Premium at $88 plus $13, and Elite at $134 plus $17. A sale marked as ending 29 November 2026 offers 70% off the base fee for three months. For 10 employees, Workforce Payroll costs $120 a month at list price.
Does ADP RUN publish its pricing?
No. ADP's RUN page does not show a price and directs visitors to request one. It describes four packages, from Essential Payroll to HR Pro Payroll & HR, and advertises up to six months of free payroll subject to linked terms. Ask for the price after the promotion in writing before signing.
Which payroll software is best for a small accounting client with 10 employees?
For most 10-person clients, Gusto Simple at $109 a month is the best starting point, because it is the cheapest published option we compared and carries the highest editor score, 4.6 out of 5. If the client already uses QuickBooks Online, QuickBooks Workforce Payroll at $120 a month deserves a trial.
When must employers e-file W-2 and 1099 forms?
The IRS e-file threshold is 10 returns, counted across all information return types together under T.D. 9972, so an employer with four W-2s and six 1099-NECs must e-file. The IRS also says recipient statements are generally due by 31 January, so check payroll set-up well before year end.
Can an accountant get free access to Gusto?
Yes, according to our directory record, which notes that Gusto Pro for accountants is free. It gives a firm a dashboard across client companies. Confirm the terms and which client tasks it covers on Gusto's site when you sign up, because we read this from the verified directory entry rather than a live page.
Sources
- Gusto: pricing plans as recorded in The AI Ledger directory, verified 13 November 2026
- ADP: RUN Powered by ADP
- Intuit: QuickBooks Payroll pricing
- IRS: Depositing and reporting employment taxes
- IRS: Employment tax due dates
- IRS: Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC
Recommended
Keep reading
- Gusto Pricing for Accountants 2026: Gusto Pro, Plans and Add-onsAn in-depth look at Gusto US payroll: every plan and add-on price, three worked cost examples including multi-state and a UK client's US subsidiary, Gusto Pro for firms, the AI features, where it falls short, and when Deel, Warp, Every or Paylocity fit better.
- Rippling Pricing 2026: Payroll, EOR, UK Costs and Worked ExamplesAn in-depth look at Rippling: what its per-employee pricing does and does not publish, three worked cost examples, US tax filing, global payroll, EOR and UK RTI, the AI claims, where it falls short, and when Gusto, Deel, Remote or Employment Hero fit better.
- QuickBooks Pricing UK 2026: Every Plan From £10 a MonthIntuit's five UK QuickBooks Online plans list at £10 to £128 a month. Here is what each includes for MTD, what payroll adds, what accountants pay through Intuit Accountant Suite and ProPartner, and how the price compares with Xero, Sage and FreeAgent.
Free: a practice AI policy template
A ready-to-adapt policy for using AI tools with client data, in Word and PDF. Free with the 5-minute Friday brief on AI tools for accountants.
We email you the template and the Friday brief. Unsubscribe in one click.