Accounting Software Evaluation Criteria: CFO Scorecard 2027
As of November 2026, the accounting software evaluation criteria that matter most to a CFO or controller are controls and security, ledger integration, close and reconciliation fit, client-data handling and total cost, scored on a weighted scorecard. Weight controls and integration at 20% each, and prove them in a mini-close on real data. List price for 10 users on QuickBooks Online Advanced is $340 a month.
TL;DR:
- Score every vendor on seven weighted criteria out of 100: controls 20, integration 20, close 15, AI and data handling 15, reporting 10, cost 10, viability 10.
- Treat a SOC 2 Type II report as a gate, not a score: the AICPA says SOC 2 reports cover security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy.
- Under 16 CFR 314.4, firms covered by the FTC Safeguards Rule must contract for safeguards and periodically assess service providers.
- QuickBooks Online Advanced lists at $340 a month for up to 25 users, so 10 users cost $4,080 a year or $34 per user per month.
- Run a parallel mini-close on real transactions before signing; a score on paper is not evidence.
Table of Contents
- What criteria should a CFO or controller use to evaluate accounting software?
- How do you build a weighted scorecard, with a worked example?
- Which security and data questions must a vendor answer?
- How should you test integration and close speed?
- How much does accounting software cost at 10 and 50 users?
- What do vendors disclose today?
- Copy this: scorecard and vendor question list
- Why does independent evidence matter when choosing accounting software?
- Realistic expectations: a score is a starting point
- Find your next accounting software tool through The AI Ledger
- Frequently asked questions
What criteria should a CFO or controller use to evaluate accounting software?
Use seven criteria: controls and security, ledger and system integration, close and reconciliation fit, AI and client-data handling, reporting, total cost, and vendor viability. Most published checklists run to 25 points or more, but a finance team can only weigh about seven things at once, so group the rest beneath these headings.
Each criterion needs a test, not an opinion:
- Controls and security. Ask for the vendor's own SOC 2 Type II report, not the cloud host's. A host's report covers infrastructure, not the application you will use.
- Integration. Check whether the tool syncs transactions continuously or loads a trial balance in batches, and which of your payroll, expense, billing and bank systems it reaches.
- Close and reconciliation. Time a real reconciliation and count late adjustments per close, not only days to close.
- AI and data handling. Find out where data is hosted, whether the vendor says it trains models on your data, and whether the tool can write back to the ledger or only read it.
- Reporting. Check that a controller can build and change a report without an IT ticket.
- Total cost. Price the tool at 10 and 50 users, including migration, add-ons and payroll.
- Vendor viability. Look at how long the product has existed, who owns it and what happens to your data if it closes or is bought.
Pro Tip: Write the pass or fail gates before you look at any demo. A tool that fails a gate, such as no SOC 2 report, should not reach the scorecard at all.
How do you build a weighted scorecard, with a worked example?
Give each criterion a weight that sums to 100, score each vendor from 1 to 5, multiply weight by score, add the results and divide by 5. The vendor with the highest total wins only if it also passes every gate. The weights below suit a 10 to 50 person finance team; change them if your risk is different.
| Criterion | Weight | Option A | Option B | Option C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Controls and security | 20 | 4 | 5 | 3 |
| Integration | 20 | 5 | 3 | 4 |
| Close and reconciliation | 15 | 3 | 5 | 4 |
| AI and data handling | 15 | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Reporting | 10 | 4 | 3 | 5 |
| Total cost | 10 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| Vendor viability | 10 | 4 | 3 | 1 |
The options are illustrative, not real products. The arithmetic for Option A is (20×4) + (20×5) + (15×3) + (15×4) + (10×4) + (10×3) + (10×4) = 80 + 100 + 45 + 60 + 40 + 30 + 40 = 395, and 395 ÷ 5 = 79 out of 100.
| Option | Weighted points | Score out of 100 | Gate result |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 395 | 79 | Passes |
| B | 380 | 76 | Passes |
| C | 385 | 77 | Fails viability gate (score of 1) |
Option C beats Option B on paper, yet a viability score of 1 should stop it. That is why gates sit beside the scorecard. A close result, 79 against 77, also tells you the decision rests on the mini-close, not the arithmetic.
Which security and data questions must a vendor answer?
A vendor must tell you where your data lives, who can access it, what it is used for and which independent reports back the claims. The AICPA says its SOC 2 reports are relevant to security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy, and describes SOC reports as information needed to assess the risks of outsourcing. Ask which of those five areas the report covers and whether it is Type II, which tests controls over a period.
If your firm prepares tax returns or handles client financial information, a legal duty applies too. Under 16 CFR 314.4, the FTC Safeguards Rule requires you to take reasonable steps to select capable service providers, require safeguards by contract and periodically assess them based on risk. A SOC 2 report supports that file, but it does not replace your own oversight.
For AI features, the NIST AI Risk Management Framework, released on 26 January 2023 as voluntary guidance, is a sensible vocabulary for the questions. Ask the vendor:
- Is customer data used to train or improve models, and can you opt out in writing?
- Is AI output traceable to source transactions so a reviewer can check it?
- Does the AI act on the ledger, or only suggest?
Pro Tip: Get the training answer in the contract, not on a web page. The Ledger's listings record "not stated" where a vendor does not say, and that is a prompt to ask, not a reason to assume.
How should you test integration and close speed?
Run a mini-close on real data from your last closed month, in parallel with your current process. Integration depth is the main differentiator: some tools load trial-balance snapshots in batches, while others sync continuously at transaction level with the ledger.
A practical test plan:
- Connect the tool to a copy or sandbox of your ledger and two feeder systems, such as payroll and bank.
- Reconcile three accounts of different difficulty: a bank account, a subledger and one intercompany or clearing account.
- Record the minutes spent, the number of exceptions and the number of adjustments posted after the close was called complete.
- Have the controller, not the vendor, build one new report.
- End the parallel run only after two consecutive closes tie out within a variance you agreed in advance.
For a firm already on QuickBooks, the question is whether the new tool reads the ledger, writes back, or both. Compare options such as Numeric and FloQast, both listed as read and write, against reporting tools such as Fathom, listed as read only. Read-only access lowers the blast radius of a mistake; write access saves more time. Neither is better in the abstract.
How much does accounting software cost at 10 and 50 users?
At 10 users, QuickBooks Online Advanced costs $340 a month at list price, or $4,080 a year, which is $34 per user per month. The QuickBooks pricing page, read on 8 November 2026, lists Simple Start at $38, Essentials at $85, Plus at $140 and Advanced at $340, with a 50% discount for three months shown on the first bill.
| Plan | List price per month | Users | Cost per user at 10 users |
|---|---|---|---|
| Essentials | $85 | 3 | Not enough seats |
| Plus | $140 | 5 | Not enough seats |
| Advanced | $340 | 25 | $340 ÷ 10 = $34 |
Two sums matter. First, the user caps are bundled per tier, so the sixth user on Plus forces an upgrade to Advanced: $140 becomes $340, an extra $200 a month or $2,400 a year. Second, at 25 users Advanced falls to $13.60 per user per month ($340 ÷ 25), which is why seat count changes the answer.
At 50 users the Advanced plan, capped at 25 users on the pricing page, no longer covers the team, and the closing tools are mostly quote-only. BlackLine's directory record cites a Vendr median of $40,125 a year, or $3,343.75 a month ($40,125 ÷ 12). That is a market median, not a quote for your size.
Pro Tip: Ask every quote-only vendor for two written prices, one for 10 users and one for 50, and add migration, onboarding and any per-entity fees before comparing.
What do vendors disclose today?
Most vendors disclose hosting but few disclose AI training. The table uses The AI Ledger's directory records, each verified against the vendor's site on the date shown, so "not stated" means the vendor's pages we read did not say.
| Tool | Editor score | Price | Hosting | Trains on client data | Ledger access |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Planful | 4.3 out of 5 | Quote | US, UK/Europe, Canada, Australia regions | No (vendor) | Read only |
| Basis | 4.4 out of 5 | Quote | US (vendor) | No (vendor) | Read and write |
| FloQast | 4.6 out of 5 | Quote | Not stated | Not stated | Read and write |
| Numeric | 4.6 out of 5 | Quote | Not stated | Not stated | Read and write |
| Digits | 4.5 out of 5 | $65, $100 or $250 per entity per month | Not stated | Not stated | Not applicable |
| Puzzle | 4.4 out of 5 | $30 to $360 per entity per month | US servers | Not stated | Not applicable |
Planful was last verified on 2 November 2026, Basis on 26 October, FloQast on 7 November, Numeric on 25 October, Digits on 1 November and Puzzle on 7 November. Digits and Puzzle are ledgers themselves, so they price per entity rather than per user: ten entities on Puzzle's Complete plan at $120 would be $1,200 a month before the annual-billing discount the vendor describes. Browse more in the month-end close category, the reporting category or compare any two on the compare page.
Copy this: scorecard and vendor question list
Paste this into a spreadsheet. Fill the weights first, then score after each demo and again after the mini-close.
| Criterion | Weight | Gate (pass/fail) | Vendor 1 | Vendor 2 | Vendor 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Controls and security | 20 | SOC 2 Type II, vendor's own | |||
| Integration | 20 | Reaches ledger, bank, payroll | |||
| Close and reconciliation | 15 | Mini-close completed | |||
| AI and data handling | 15 | No training on our data, in contract | |||
| Reporting | 10 | Controller builds a report alone | |||
| Total cost | 10 | Quote at 10 and 50 users | |||
| Vendor viability | 10 | Exit and data export terms |
Questions to send every vendor:
- Send your latest SOC 2 Type II report and name the trust criteria it covers.
- Where is customer data hosted, by which provider, in which region?
- Is customer data used to train models? Confirm in the contract.
- Can the tool write to our ledger? Which actions need human approval?
- What is the full price at 10 and 50 users, including onboarding?
- How do we export all our data if we leave, and in what format?
- Who owns the company, and has it been acquired or funded in the last 24 months?
- Which Safeguards Rule documentation can you provide for our service provider file?
Why does independent evidence matter when choosing accounting software?
Vendor pages describe the product at its best, while independent scores and dated checks show what a buyer can verify. The AI Ledger scores each listing on the same criteria and records a last-verified date, so you can see how old a claim is. Scores are editorial judgements from the vendor's published material, not hands-on tests. Start with the full directory, and use vendor claims as questions for the demo.
Realistic expectations: a score is a starting point
A scorecard narrows the field to two or three vendors; it does not pick the winner. Plan for a parallel run of two closes, expect the first to be slower, and budget for migration before you sign.
Find your next accounting software tool through The AI Ledger
The month-end close category lists close and reconciliation platforms, and the finder shortlists tools by team size and ledger. If you run on QuickBooks ↗, start there and filter for read and write access. The QuickBooks listing records the ledger side.
Frequently asked questions
What are the main criteria for evaluating accounting software?
Evaluate seven criteria: controls and security, integration with your ledger and other systems, close and reconciliation fit, AI and client-data handling, reporting, total cost and vendor viability. Weight them to total 100, score each vendor from 1 to 5, and treat gates such as a SOC 2 Type II report as pass or fail.
How do you weight an accounting software scorecard?
Start with controls and integration at 20 points each, close and reconciliation and AI and data handling at 15 each, then reporting, cost and viability at 10 each. Multiply weight by score, add them up and divide by 5 for a score out of 100. Adjust weights if your risk profile differs.
Is a SOC 2 report enough to approve an accounting software vendor?
No. A SOC 2 report is evidence about security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality or privacy, but you still need to read its scope and period. If you are covered by the FTC Safeguards Rule, you must also contract for safeguards and periodically assess the provider yourself.
How much does QuickBooks Online cost for 10 users?
On the QuickBooks pricing page read on 8 November 2026, only Advanced covers 10 users, as Plus allows 5. Advanced lists at $340 a month, which is $4,080 a year or $34 per user per month, before any introductory discount or add-ons such as payroll.
How long should a parallel run last when switching accounting software?
Run the new and old tools in parallel until two consecutive closes reconcile within a variance you set beforehand. For most teams that means at least two month-end cycles. Stopping after one clean close risks missing issues that appear only in quarter-end or intercompany entries.
Should AI features count in accounting software evaluation?
Yes, but as questions about data, not as a bonus. Ask where data is hosted, whether the vendor trains on it, whether output is traceable to source transactions and whether the AI can write to the ledger. The NIST AI Risk Management Framework offers a voluntary vocabulary for these checks.
Sources
- eCFR: 16 CFR 314.4, Elements of the information security program (FTC Safeguards Rule)
- AICPA and CIMA: System and Organization Controls (SOC) suite of services
- NIST: AI Risk Management Framework
- Intuit: QuickBooks Online pricing
- The AI Ledger: tool directory records (BlackLine pricing note citing Vendr, and the tools in the table)
Recommended
Keep reading
- Month-End Close Software UK 2026: AI Tools and Prices per ClientThe four kinds of month-end close software, what each costs a UK practice at 10, 40 and 100 clients from published prices, where they fall short, and which to choose for QuickBooks, Xero and in-house finance teams.
- Best AI Tools for UK Accountants 2026: 30 Tools Scored, Prices CheckedOne top pick for each of eight practice jobs, from receipt capture to audit, with editor scores, published UK prices and what each vendor says about hosting and training on client data.
- Types of accounting automation software: 2026 UK guideDiscover the types of accounting automation software for 2026. Learn how to streamline your financial processes and boost efficiency.
Free: a practice AI policy template
A ready-to-adapt policy for using AI tools with client data, in Word and PDF. Free with the 5-minute Friday brief on AI tools for accountants.
We email you the template and the Friday brief. Unsubscribe in one click.