Punchcard review
Editor score: 4.4 out of 5 | Category: Audit & fraud detection | Sold in: US | Last verified: 2026-11-15
Agentic audit workspace that turns each request or test into a punchcard, with CoAudit drafting cited workpapers
Our verdict
A well-structured audit agent with proper citation trails and real adoption, but its flagship agent is still in beta and pricing needs a sales call.
Review
Punchcard's idea is that audit work goes wrong in the hand-offs: the request that was never quite specified, the evidence saved in the wrong folder, the test nobody can trace back to source. Putting each piece of work into one structured card, with an agent doing the first pass and the reviewer signing off in the same place, attacks that directly.
What it does well. The structure is the strength. Instructions, evidence, agent output and sign-off live together, so a reviewer can see exactly what was asked and what was done. Every CoAudit result carries reasoning and a citation, which is what quality reviewers and inspectors will want to see. Coverage of substantive testing, SOX operating effectiveness and unrecorded liability searches is broad, and the Financial Statement Review module, with trial balance tie-out and disclosure checks, adds value at the end of the file. Working inside Excel and Word reduces change management, and named users such as RSM and Richey May show real adoption.
Where it falls short. Pricing is not published and every route in is a demo. CoAudit is still marked as beta on the site, so firms should be clear about what is production-ready before relying on it. Efficiency claims such as up to ten times faster testing are the company's own case studies. Engagement types are US-centred, including employee benefit plan audits and SOC 2 work, and nothing on the site addresses UK standards. No ledger or audit file integrations are named beyond Excel and Word.
Best for. US CPA firms and internal audit teams, roughly 11 to 50 auditors and up, that want structured, reviewable agent work across substantive and control testing. A trial should take one area, such as revenue testing, run it through punchcards and time preparation and review against last year. UK firms wanting cited AI work inside Excel should compare DataSnipper and Moby Analytics, and those after a full engagement platform should look at Fieldguide.
Verdict. A well-structured audit agent with proper citation trails and real adoption, but its flagship agent is still in beta and pricing needs a sales call.
Key features
- Punchcards holding request, evidence, agent work and sign-off together
- CoAudit agent with reasoning and source citations across Excel and Word
- Workpaper agent with tolerances and tick marks
- Financial Statement Review with trial balance tie-out and disclosure checks
- SOC 2 certified, with GDPR compliance available
Punchcard pricing
Custom pricing on request
| Plan | Price | Billing | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Punchcard (Request, Workpaper, CoAudit, Financial Statement Review) | On request | Not stated | Client request tracking, AI CoAudit agent that reads evidence and prepares source-linked workpapers, financial statement review; Book a demo only |
Free trial: None stated; Book a demo only
Who it fits
US CPA firms running external audits, and in-house internal audit teams doing operational, financial, IT and SOX work, that want each client request and audit procedure organised as a card with evidence, agent output and reviewer sign-off together. Firms that want AI-drafted workpapers with citations rather than a new ledger tool.
Who it does not fit
UK practices focused on bookkeeping, tax or compliance rather than audit, and firms that need UK or EU data residency: servers are in the US, there is no published price and no trial.
Data and integrations
- Data hosting: US ('Our servers are located in the United States'); provider not stated
- Trains on customer data: not stated
- Ledger access: not applicable
- Works with: Microsoft Excel, Microsoft Word, Browser-based
Common questions
What is Punchcard?
Punchcard, formerly Agentive and built by Substantive AI, is an audit work-management platform. Every client request or audit task becomes a punchcard holding the instructions, evidence, the agent's work and the reviewer's sign-off, and moves through request, test and review stages.
What does the CoAudit agent do?
CoAudit works across Punchcard, Excel and Word, reading contracts, invoices, bank statements, payroll, debt agreements and offering memos. It gives reasoning and a citation to source evidence for each result. The site still labels it as in beta, so treat it with caution.
Is Punchcard SOC 2 certified and GDPR compliant?
Punchcard says it is SOC 2 certified and offers GDPR compliance. Those are the vendor's statements, so ask for the report and confirm where data is hosted. It names RSM, Richey May, RSM Ebner Stolz and Stambaugh Ness as users.
Does Punchcard suit UK audit firms?
Possibly, but check first. Its engagement types are US-centred, including employee benefit plan audits and SOC 2 work, and nothing on the site addresses UK standards. UK firms wanting cited AI work inside Excel may want to compare other tools in the audit category.
Changelog
- 2026-11-04: Punchcard in Excel launched: agent work verified cell by cell with citations
- 2026-06-12: Rebranded from Agentive to Punchcard (company Substantive AI, Inc., founded 2023)
- 2026-05-05: EBP audit co-audited with an AI agent
- 2026-03-17: AI-powered Financial Statement Review launched
- 2025-02-15: Client requests feature launched
How this review was put together
Punchcard scores 4.4 out of 5. The editor sets the score on five questions: does it do the job a practice buys it for, does it fit the practices it serves (UK, US or both) and their software, what it costs once per-client pricing is counted, how hard it is to set up and leave, and how much of what Punchcard claims can be checked.
The evidence is Punchcard's own published material: 5 pages on pricing, product, data and security, last checked 2026-11-15, read against the other tools we list in Audit & fraud detection. Where Punchcard does not say something, we write not stated rather than guess.
- https://www.punchcard.com
- https://www.punchcard.com/is/security
- https://www.punchcard.com/is/privacy
- https://blog.punchcard.com
- https://blog.punchcard.com/posts/why-agentive-became-punchcard
What the score is not: it is not an average of user reviews, and we do not run tools on live client books. It cannot be bought. A paid Verified profile adds screenshots, a demo and a right of reply, never a higher score or a better place in a list.
Independent review by The AI Ledger editorial team. Scores are never for sale, and affiliate links are labelled.